To what extent should magazines be held responsible for the
social ramifications of the representations they offer?
The four magazine covers I analysed for a pre-task were all
aimed at teenage/young adult girls. After comparing them all it really shows
that from reading the type of magazines and articles within, it gives a
perspective over what the ‘norm’ is for girls to look and act like. Social
ramification is the bad effect of doing a certain thing, so when it comes to
reading these teenage magazines this could be things like peer pressure or self
consciousness. When it comes to teenage girls, there’s already a lot of stress
and of peer pressure to have your hair in a certain cut, wear different types
of make-up and wear the best clothes that fits in with your friendship group,
from a young age, girls feel the need to fit into a certain stereotype of ‘pretty’
or ‘fashionable’ and they fear the confrontation that would likely come from
looking or dressing differently than what’s supposedly expected from them. So
when reading the magazines, it makes it that little bit harder. The articles
are almost telling you what to wear, how to apply your make-up and which brand
to get or how to get a boyfriend. One of the worst social ramifications that
magazines represent is weight. The girls that fill the pages are always skinny
and the stereotype of either pretty or sexy and it gives the idea that being
skinny is the normal way and it gives a perception to girls who may be bigger
that being slightly larger is a bad thing, and from this there’s a lot of
problems with teenage girls and eating problems from anorexia to bulimia. But
this is only because the magazines are almost shoving the way people should
look and dress down their throats. The Hypodermic Needle theory comes into this
as teenage girls will believe anything they read and will act or do things to
their body to become this stereotype which isn't what they should be like, only
what girls are expected to become from the lines in these articles. There are problems now with girls as young as
12 and 13 that have been in hospital from eating disorders. It’s not only
magazines that are responsible for these issues, magazines are only a part of
this. A lot of media gives out hidden meanings of ‘the perfect girl’ especially
shows on television, most of them involving stereotypes of ‘pretty’ girls, and
things like ‘America’s Next Top Model’ giving a message that only super skinny,
pretty and tall girls are the right fit to become a model. Also newspapers don’t
help. When it comes to page 3 girls, this gives out more stereotypes a girl
should fit into. The page 3 girls always have big breasts, which for all girls
can make them feel self-conscious if they aren't only enough to produce them
yet or if when they have aren't big enough, which leads to another social
ramification of Plastic Surgery, millions of girls now go through surgery to
get tucks and lifts to get better cheekbones, bums, stomachs and and boob jobs
to go up a size because they don’t believe they’re a normal size because of
stereotypes and perceptions of the normal thing. So the media is defiantly quite
responsible for how children and young adults are becoming, girls are growing
up now self conscious and have a lot of peer pressure to become something that’s
not at all natural which when doing so, can take turns for the worst.
Well done, you make some good points here about the negative influence magazines aimed at teenage girls can have, in particular the pressure they feel to conform. The rest of your blog is mostly up to date. Please ensure you post a student magazine written proposal and some examples of student photography from the last lesson
ReplyDelete